Influencer Agencies vs. MCNs: What’s the Difference?
In the ever-expanding world of influencer marketing, brands often face a critical decision: should you partner with an influencer agency or a multi-channel network (MCN)? While they both serve as intermediaries in the influencer marketing ecosystem, their approaches and priorities differ significantly.
Influencer Agencies:
These are third-party companies that specialize in connecting brands with influencers to execute marketing campaigns.
They typically represent a wide range of influencers, from nano to macro, across various niches.
Agencies focus on advertiser needs and are adept at creating brand-aligned strategies.
These are organizations that work closely with content creators, usually on platforms like YouTube or TikTok, to help them grow their channels.
They provide creators with tools, resources, and often exclusive brand opportunities.
MCNs are typically more creator-centric, prioritizing the success and profitability of their roster.
The Pros and Cons
Influencer Agencies
Benefits:
Pro-advertiser mindset: Agencies are laser-focused on delivering ROI for brands. While they support influencers, their primary goal is to ensure campaigns align with advertiser objectives.
Diverse creator pool: No matter what type of influencer you’re targeting—lifestyle, tech, fitness—agencies can provide a curated list tailored to your needs.
Fresh campaigns, every time: Agencies ensure you’re not constantly working with the same influencers, keeping your audience engaged with new faces and perspectives.
Transparent pricing: Agencies often charge a fixed percentage, offering a clear and fair cost structure for brands.
Drawbacks:
May not have exclusive access to certain influencers.
Less focus on long-term partnerships with individual creators.
MCNs
Benefits:
Creator-first approach: MCNs prioritize the growth and success of their influencers, meaning creators under their wing are often well-supported and motivated.
Exclusive talent: MCNs may have exclusive contracts with influencers, giving you access to creators not available elsewhere.
Drawbacks:
Pro-creator focus: Their priority is their influencers, which may lead to campaigns that don’t always maximize brand ROI.
Limited variety: MCNs often have a narrower roster of creators, restricting options if you’re looking for specific niches or styles.
Variable pricing: MCN pricing models can vary widely, often depending on the influencer, campaign type, and the MCN’s cut—making it harder to predict costs.
Why Brands Should Lean Toward Influencer Agencies
Aligned Goals: Agencies are built to serve advertisers, ensuring your brand objectives are front and center. While MCNs might cater to creators’ needs first, agencies are structured to maximize your campaign's effectiveness.
Creative Flexibility: Working with an agency gives you access to a broad and diverse creator pool, ensuring you can switch things up and maintain audience interest with fresh influencer collaborations.
Cost Efficiency: Agencies typically operate on a fixed-percentage commission, giving you a clearer picture of campaign costs. With MCNs, the lack of standardization can lead to unexpected expenses.
Conclusion
Both influencer agencies and MCNs have their strengths, but for brands looking to maximize ROI, maintain creative flexibility, and enjoy transparent pricing, agencies are the way to go. By choosing an agency, you’re not just tapping into influencer marketing—you’re building strategic campaigns that drive meaningful results.
Comments